I thought that the section of chapter fifteen discussing fallacies and fallacies in responding especially was important this week. One of the most common types is the ad hominem fallacy, or the against the person fallacy (323). When a public speaker gets up in front of the class and provides several valid and influential points they could very well be either not taken seriously or altogether ignored because of other biases. I think that this type of attitude is extremely dangerous, as well as counter-productive in the grander scheme of things. If people are not even willing to open their ears to a speaker because of bigotry or stereotypes we stand to lose out in everyday conversation and public speeches alike.
Another type of fallacy that is similar to the aforementioned is the guilt by association fallacy which causes an audience to lump the public speaker into an undesirable group, therefore hurting their credibility (324). The straw man fallacy is especially important in terms of public speaking as politicians often employ its use during their campaigns. By over exaggerating their opponent’s positions on key issues they in effect lessen the validity of the politician’s stances (324). Finally, loaded word fallacies seek to use words that will distract an audience in an effort to prove their point. This type of fallacy often occurs when respondents want to refute a speaker’s claims without gathering evidence to the contrary (324).
Daily Truth
Sunday, April 29, 2012
Reasoning
I recently tried to convince some of my coworkers of the shady and deceptive nature of the owners of our favorite basketball team. I used deductive reasoning at first, explaining to them that just because the owners have contributed to the community via charity or philanthropy it does not necessarily make them good people. Nearly every major sports owner in the world engages in philanthropy so I suggested that we should not let those contributions from our owners be considered their saving grace. I was basically implying that what applies as a general rule to all owners also applies to our owners. I think that this was a very effective way of explaining my stance because it is undeniable hard to refute the evidence.
I also used causal reasoning by bringing up the horrid decisions made by our ownership over the past decade. From coaching, personnel and draft decisions all the way down to ticket prices I painted a vivid picture of just why our owners are a big reason for our current plight. While one of my coworkers was not so easily convinced, the other agreed with my wholeheartedly. While there still is the possibility of my cause-effect link being flawed (313) I still think that I did a good job of spelling everything out for my coworkers. They were definitely more informed about the King's ownership after our conversation and may even have changed their mind about their feelings toward them after we finished.
I also used causal reasoning by bringing up the horrid decisions made by our ownership over the past decade. From coaching, personnel and draft decisions all the way down to ticket prices I painted a vivid picture of just why our owners are a big reason for our current plight. While one of my coworkers was not so easily convinced, the other agreed with my wholeheartedly. While there still is the possibility of my cause-effect link being flawed (313) I still think that I did a good job of spelling everything out for my coworkers. They were definitely more informed about the King's ownership after our conversation and may even have changed their mind about their feelings toward them after we finished.
Sunday, April 22, 2012
MMS and Problem/Solution
I definitely prefer Monroe's Motivated Sequence were I picking between it and the problem/solution organization pattern for our final speech. The reason being that I really prefer the needs versus wants method laid out by Monroe. I really identified with his five steps of his motivated sequence: attention, need, satisfaction, attention, visualization and action. Step one of this process is getting your audiences attention, which is done by using an attention getter in our speeches. Step two consists of getting your audience to feel a need or want. For example, my speech will seek to tell my audience they need to recycle from the very beginning.
Step three of the sequence is satisfying your want or need, something that can be done by making a clear statement on what your stance on your topic is. Step four consists of visualizing the results, which is really just another way of saying how your audience will be convinced of your argument. You can use either the positive, negative, or contrast method to show your audience what the different options for your topic are. For my speech, I feel like discussing the positive effects of recycling would be appropriate. Step five is the "call to action" phase of the sequence. This is precisely where an effective and memorable conclusion comes into play, as the audience needs to get a big motivational statement from the speaker.
The problem/solution arrangement could also be effective in my opinion, however I would not want to become a slave to the causal pattern. This type of organization focuses on a specific problem followed by what the speaker feels is the proper solution. The problem portion of this pattern occurs when the speaker tells their audience the harmful or positive effects of said problem. The speaker then presents what they feel will best solve the problem. While either of these methods are a surefire way of having a great speech when used effectively, I still think I lean more toward Monroe's Motivated Sequence. I just really like the attention to detail in this sequence and feel it would result in a tremendous persuasive speech.
Step three of the sequence is satisfying your want or need, something that can be done by making a clear statement on what your stance on your topic is. Step four consists of visualizing the results, which is really just another way of saying how your audience will be convinced of your argument. You can use either the positive, negative, or contrast method to show your audience what the different options for your topic are. For my speech, I feel like discussing the positive effects of recycling would be appropriate. Step five is the "call to action" phase of the sequence. This is precisely where an effective and memorable conclusion comes into play, as the audience needs to get a big motivational statement from the speaker.
The problem/solution arrangement could also be effective in my opinion, however I would not want to become a slave to the causal pattern. This type of organization focuses on a specific problem followed by what the speaker feels is the proper solution. The problem portion of this pattern occurs when the speaker tells their audience the harmful or positive effects of said problem. The speaker then presents what they feel will best solve the problem. While either of these methods are a surefire way of having a great speech when used effectively, I still think I lean more toward Monroe's Motivated Sequence. I just really like the attention to detail in this sequence and feel it would result in a tremendous persuasive speech.
Chapter 14
The five types of audiences outlined in chapter fourteen provide a good example of the complexities involved with public speaking. As stated in the text, the key is to "understand how to reach them effectively". The five common audience positions: negative or hostile, positive or sympathetic, divided, uniformed, and apathetic (287).
Since negative audiences would give immediate pushback during one of these speeches, it would be imperative that the persuasive speakers be extra convincing once their speech reaches conclusion. The only problem I really have with this type of audience is they may be overly biased, to the point where if the speaker made great points the audience would still be negative.
Positive and divided audiences would be preferable for all of the speeches we give or have given this semester. After all, you would not want to give a speech and have an audience not at least attempt to be ambivalent on a subject. I would even take an uniformed audiences who, "are unfamiliar with your topic and have no opinion on it" (290).
It is funny because apathetic audiences could really be present in any speech at any given time. If we really looked into the statistics I am sure we would find that most people who are bored or simply have other things on their mind will be apathetic during a speech. When I read about all of these audiences I conclude that said audiences could really comprise almost all of the five types simultaneously. This is definitely something I will remember when giving my speech tomorrow, as the key to persuading them will be presenting a speech that covers all the basis while also being memorable.
Since negative audiences would give immediate pushback during one of these speeches, it would be imperative that the persuasive speakers be extra convincing once their speech reaches conclusion. The only problem I really have with this type of audience is they may be overly biased, to the point where if the speaker made great points the audience would still be negative.
Positive and divided audiences would be preferable for all of the speeches we give or have given this semester. After all, you would not want to give a speech and have an audience not at least attempt to be ambivalent on a subject. I would even take an uniformed audiences who, "are unfamiliar with your topic and have no opinion on it" (290).
It is funny because apathetic audiences could really be present in any speech at any given time. If we really looked into the statistics I am sure we would find that most people who are bored or simply have other things on their mind will be apathetic during a speech. When I read about all of these audiences I conclude that said audiences could really comprise almost all of the five types simultaneously. This is definitely something I will remember when giving my speech tomorrow, as the key to persuading them will be presenting a speech that covers all the basis while also being memorable.
Saturday, April 21, 2012
Persuasion
I definitely feel like I am emerged in a sea of persuasion because of all the marketing and subliminal messaging that occurs in media as well as in every day life. Something that comes to mind immediately is the many advertisement questions that are posed while enjoying a television or movie online. These marketing questionnaires seek to persuade me to buy a product, although they double as a form of feedback for the companies offering the product.
Persuasion also comes in the form of my wife, who is constantly giving me her two cents in all matters. My boss is yet another source of persuasive techniques as he seems to give me hints and mental nudges frequently on what he wants done and how I should do it. The important thing to remember in all of this is that life is really one big persuasive speech. In our jobs, school and personal lives we have to convince not only ourselves, but also others of how we can help in our areas of expertise.
Think of any job interview you have had in the past or present. You will notice that throughout the duration of said interview you made a point of referencing things that made you more appealing. By describing a body of work that makes you more desirable to an employer you very well could have gotten a job because of the use of persuasion. We definitely live in an era of persuasion, as evidenced by the constant advertisements and subliminal messaging we see in the media.
Sunday, April 15, 2012
Flickr Discussion Response
There is definitely something to be said about the double standard that exists for men and women. The very first example of using non-inclusive language from the Flickr thread is evidence of this. Adult males are referred to as men, whereas adult females are often referred to as “girls”. Since inclusive language is important to keeping your audience from thinking about stereotypes and the like, it becomes very important to avoid such pitfalls like “girl”.
As the text states using this type of language can cause your audience to flat out stop listening to you during a speech (194). As I kept reading the thread I noticed the conversation branch off into a discussion about “net speak” and avoiding the use of proper English online. I thought this was a great example of the power language holds over us, which is something the OP of the thread wanted to make readers think about.
Using Nonsexist language seems to be the key to avoid controversy or misunderstandings. This is no easy task, as the gap separating how men and women view things can be very different. The best plan of attack is to avoid non-inclusive language altogether by carefully choosing which words to avoid during your speech. I recently mentioned my Aunt and her never having caught a fish before I taught her how. Although the class may or may not have made the connection between female and never catching a fish, I could have avoided it altogether by calling her a non-gender specific title such as “in-law”.
As the text states using this type of language can cause your audience to flat out stop listening to you during a speech (194). As I kept reading the thread I noticed the conversation branch off into a discussion about “net speak” and avoiding the use of proper English online. I thought this was a great example of the power language holds over us, which is something the OP of the thread wanted to make readers think about.
Using Nonsexist language seems to be the key to avoid controversy or misunderstandings. This is no easy task, as the gap separating how men and women view things can be very different. The best plan of attack is to avoid non-inclusive language altogether by carefully choosing which words to avoid during your speech. I recently mentioned my Aunt and her never having caught a fish before I taught her how. Although the class may or may not have made the connection between female and never catching a fish, I could have avoided it altogether by calling her a non-gender specific title such as “in-law”.
Chapter 10 and 12 Speech Buddy
Something that I thought was really helpful in the speech buddy videos was the tips for making your speech more audience centered. Using current events, inclusive language and maintaining good posture during a speech are all very important. I also thought that the advice of using metaphor, alliteration and the like was also very useful. Using humor sparingly is definitely something else I agree with from the chapter 10 videos. Making language choices was also very helpful to me because the way we word our speeches must be taken into consideration.
The chapter 12 videos yielded something I thought to be very important as one of the videos highlighted physical delivery. Eye contact, facial, gestures, movements and appearance are the five factors discusses. All of these are vital to an effective speech, as the audience is more likely to both gain and maintain interest if all five are used rather then just a few of them. The bit about podiums at the end was very interesting because it really is true that speeches sans a podium promote more natural body movement. I think that the appearance aspect of a public speech is the most important of the five, as your audience might think you less credible if your appearance is lackluster.
The chapter 12 videos yielded something I thought to be very important as one of the videos highlighted physical delivery. Eye contact, facial, gestures, movements and appearance are the five factors discusses. All of these are vital to an effective speech, as the audience is more likely to both gain and maintain interest if all five are used rather then just a few of them. The bit about podiums at the end was very interesting because it really is true that speeches sans a podium promote more natural body movement. I think that the appearance aspect of a public speech is the most important of the five, as your audience might think you less credible if your appearance is lackluster.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)