I recently tried to convince some of my coworkers of the shady and deceptive nature of the owners of our favorite basketball team. I used deductive reasoning at first, explaining to them that just because the owners have contributed to the community via charity or philanthropy it does not necessarily make them good people. Nearly every major sports owner in the world engages in philanthropy so I suggested that we should not let those contributions from our owners be considered their saving grace. I was basically implying that what applies as a general rule to all owners also applies to our owners. I think that this was a very effective way of explaining my stance because it is undeniable hard to refute the evidence.
I also used causal reasoning by bringing up the horrid decisions made by our ownership over the past decade. From coaching, personnel and draft decisions all the way down to ticket prices I painted a vivid picture of just why our owners are a big reason for our current plight. While one of my coworkers was not so easily convinced, the other agreed with my wholeheartedly. While there still is the possibility of my cause-effect link being flawed (313) I still think that I did a good job of spelling everything out for my coworkers. They were definitely more informed about the King's ownership after our conversation and may even have changed their mind about their feelings toward them after we finished.
I like your strategies that you employed two different reasoning to persuade your coworkers to accept your assertion. Also, I believe that we sometimes can not just use one type of reasoning to support our ideas. The more sorts of reasoning could enhance our credibility. I like the way you use for your argument that you first applied the general principle to specific case, instead of causal reasoning. If you used the casual reasoning first, I would think you prejudice against the owners. As you detailed the owner’s mistaken decisions causing the team’s fail. Logically, when you established the general principle of the actual charity of the owners, you have given your coworker an idea that not only you against the basketball owners, but also most people. You really did a good job. In addition, I believe those owners do some charity to communities is just another kind of ads. I would not impress by their charitable deeds.
ReplyDelete